Fabio Capello claimed former side England have a "monkey on their back and then fail" when it comes to finals.
Gareth Southgate's men reached their first major final in 55 years at Euro 2020, but lost on penalties as Italy claimed their first European Championship since 1968.
England have enjoyed relative success in September's World Cup qualifiers, crushing Hungary and Andorra 4-0 before conceding a late equaliser to draw 1-1 with Poland.
In the latter game, Southgate opted to not make any substitutions – the first time the Three Lions have done so since the Euro 1996 semi-final against Germany.
And Capello believes there is a reason for the England manager's lack of substitutes in Warsaw after heartbreak in the Euro 2020 final two months ago.
"If [Southgate] doesn't make subs it means he wants this group to be convinced to be strong, as the results proved," Capello, who managed England for five years until 2012, told reporters.
"Bear in mind, they have just botched half a match versus Italy in the final, when they were overwhelmed by fear and stopped playing.
"I know England and their problems. They have that monkey on their back to get to the final and then they fail."
England are unbeaten in their last 16 international matches (W13 D3) – their longest streak without defeat since a 16-game run between September 1995 and November 1996.
A sensational strike from the skipper.— England (@England) September 9, 2021
While international teams pursue qualification for Qatar 2022, FIFA's chief of global football development, Arsene Wenger, is pushing a biennial plan for future World Cups.
The former Arsenal manager's proposition, which was put to FIFA in May, would see global football's most important tournament switch to a two-year cycle.
UEFA president Aleksander Ceferin greeted the suggestions with disdain, but Capello revealed he would support the proposed changes as a player.
"As a player, I would like the World Cup to be played every two years," the 75-year-old Italian continued.
"Four years is a long time and sometimes you are at the top of your game but when the World Cup comes you are not and you have no chance to shine.
"At the same time, waiting four years makes that trophy more coveted and important, it is bigger.
"Every two years, this value would decrease but again, as a player, I played the World Cup just once, and the second time I missed it for the width of a hair, so I would [play every two years]."